Over the past few months, I've been running ScoreCraft audits on small business websites — plumbers, bakeries, law firms, landscapers, dentists, SaaS startups, boutique shops, freelancers. All kinds.
After looking at 100 of them, some clear patterns jumped out. The same issues kept showing up, and the same easy wins kept getting ignored. I figured it was worth writing up what I found.
None of this is scientific research. It's just what I noticed. But if you run a small business website, there's a decent chance your site has at least three or four of these issues.
The Average Growth Score Was 38 out of 100
That's not great. But it makes sense when you consider that most small business websites were built once, by someone who isn't a web professional, and then mostly forgotten. The bar for "good" is low, which means the opportunity to stand out is huge.
The top-scoring sites in the group scored around 72-78. The lowest was 11. The difference between the best and worst sites wasn't budget or design — it was attention to basics.
The Most Common Issues (by How Often I Saw Them)
1. Missing meta descriptions — 73 out of 100 sites
Nearly three-quarters of the sites had pages with no meta description at all. Not bad meta descriptions — completely absent ones. When Google doesn't have a meta description, it pulls a random snippet from your page. The result usually looks awkward in search results and doesn't convince anyone to click.
Writing a decent meta description takes about 30 seconds per page. It's genuinely one of the easiest things you can do.
2. No SSL certificate or mixed content — 18 out of 100
This one surprised me. In 2026, 18% of small business sites either didn't have HTTPS at all, or had it configured but were loading images or scripts over HTTP (mixed content). Chrome flags these sites as "Not Secure" which kills trust instantly.
Most hosting providers offer free SSL now through Let's Encrypt. There's no excuse for this one anymore.
3. Thin content on key pages — 61 out of 100
The most common thin page? The homepage. Followed by service pages and the about page. I saw homepages that were literally just a logo, a photo, and a phone number. No text for Google to understand what the business does or where it operates.
The sites that ranked well had pages with 500-1,500 words of real, useful content. Not keyword-stuffed filler — actual information that a potential customer would find helpful.
4. No H1 tag or multiple H1s — 44 out of 100
Either the page had no H1 heading at all (the text was styled to look big but wasn't actually a heading tag), or it had three or four H1s because the page builder used H1 for every section.
One H1 per page. Make it descriptive. This isn't controversial — it's just often overlooked.
5. Images without alt text — 67 out of 100
Two-thirds of the sites had images with no alt text. This hurts both SEO (Google can't "see" the images) and accessibility (screen readers can't describe them). Most CMS platforms have an alt text field right in the image uploader. It takes 10 seconds per image.
6. No Google Business Profile link — 52 out of 100
For local businesses, your Google Business Profile is arguably more important than your website for local search. Over half the sites I audited had no link between their website and their GBP, and many had GBP listings that were incomplete or unverified.
7. No call-to-action on the homepage — 34 out of 100
A third of the sites didn't have a clear call-to-action on their homepage. No "Call us," no "Get a quote," no "Book now." The visitor lands on the page and has to figure out what to do next. Most won't bother.
8. No sitemap submitted to Google — 58 out of 100
More than half hadn't submitted a sitemap through Google Search Console. Many didn't have Search Console set up at all. This means they're relying on Google to discover their pages organically through links, which is slow and unreliable for small sites with few backlinks.
The Stuff That Separated Good Sites from Bad Ones
Here's what the top-scoring sites (60+) had in common that the bottom-scoring ones didn't:
- They had a blog with 5+ posts. Not groundbreaking content — just helpful, locally relevant articles that gave Google something to work with. A roofing company with blog posts about "signs you need a new roof" and "how to choose a roofing contractor in [city]" consistently outranked competitors without a blog.
- They loaded fast. Under 3 seconds on mobile. Usually this just meant they'd compressed their images and weren't using a bloated theme with 15 plugins.
- They had internal links. Their pages linked to each other in ways that made sense. The services page linked to relevant blog posts. Blog posts linked back to service pages. It created a web that search engines could follow.
- They had at least a few backlinks. Even 5-10 links from local directories, partner sites, or industry associations made a noticeable difference in rankings.
- They updated their site at least occasionally. A blog post every few weeks, an updated testimonial, a new service added. Google notices when a site hasn't changed in two years.
The Biggest Takeaway
The gap between a 35-score website and a 65-score website isn't talent, budget, or luck. It's about 4-6 hours of work on the basics: write real content, add meta descriptions, fix your headings, compress your images, submit your sitemap, and get a few links.
That's it. That's the whole secret. Most of your competitors won't do it, which is exactly why it works.
Curious where your site falls? Find out in 60 seconds.
Run a Free Audit →